Biblioteca Virtual

When and Why “Law” and “Reality” Coincide? De Jure and De Facto Judicial Independence in Mexico, Arg

Show full item record

Title: When and Why “Law” and “Reality” Coincide? De Jure and De Facto Judicial Independence in Mexico, Arg
País: United States
Idioma: English
Fuente: Fuente: Center for US-Mexican Studies, University of California San DiegoFuente: Center for US-Mexican Studies, University of California San Diego
Reseña: Our central question is: Under what circumstances can we expect a theoretically informed and reproducible measure of judicial independence de jure to be a good proxy for what we can expect to happen in reality? We argue that whether the de jure measure can be considered a good proxy for, to overestimate or to underestimate, judicial independence in reality depends on the distribution of power among the ruling political groups. Having identified those political conditions, and what Supreme Court judges can expect from them, we explore what is the likely behavior of these judges regarding decisions on cases where the government violates the rule of law or horizontal accountability. Having laid out our theoretical expectations in six different scenarios, we proceed to illustrate them using Mexico Argentina, and Chile.


Files in this item

Thumbnail Files: When-and-Why-La ... co-Argentina-and-Chile.pdf
Size: 352.2Kb
Format: PDF

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show full item record